Why every AI-made app looks the same
If your LinkedIn feed looks anything like mine, it’s full of “AI design versus my design” posts. They’re fun to scroll through. But I wanted to know what you actually get when you ask an AI app builder for the same thing more than once.
Nine tries
I gave Lovable three prompts for a running app’s home screen:
- A vague one, with almost no detail.
- A fair one, saying what the screen should show: a weekly goal, pace, time, the last run and a start button.
- A proper designer brief, with Apple’s rules, 44-point tap targets as Apple recommends, 4.5:1 contrast and native controls.
I ran each one three times, which gave me nine designs. Six came back dark, all with the same neon green. Even the designer brief produced one. And the light ones shared the same layout: a progress ring, some bars and a big start button.
Why it happens
That’s not a coincidence. These tools give you the average of what they’ve seen, and a lot of running apps online are dark and neon.
We’ve seen this before. The first AI videos still had stock-photo watermarks on them, because the model had learned from stock footage. In 2024, Figma pulled an early AI design feature because it kept producing copies of Apple’s Weather app. AI gives back what it learned from.
Why it matters
If you and your competitor both ask for a running app, you’ll probably get the same one. For a brand, that’s a real problem. If your app looks like everyone else’s, why would anyone remember it?
A familiar look can also hide familiar problems. My nine screens all looked polished. The one I tested closely still had five usability issues, from tap targets that were too small to text that ignored the size people set on their phone.
What to do about it
- Brief it properly, but don’t stop there. A better prompt helps. My designer brief still produced a dark neon screen, so a brief alone won’t make you different.
- Build from your own design system. The tools are catching up, and the best ones now build from your design system rather than the internet’s average. That makes your design system more valuable than ever.
- Use AI to explore, not to decide. Let it generate directions quickly, then have someone choose, combine and refine them with your brand and users in mind.
- Keep checking. Every improvement to my screen came from someone asking the next question.
AI will give you a thousand yeses. The job is still the no’s.
Move from AI Chaos to AI Clarity
If your organisation is experiencing fragmented pilots, unclear boundaries, regulatory anxiety or difficulty scaling beyond experimentation, it is time to move from chaos to clarity. Download the whitepaper and take the first structured step toward building AI systems that work
Take the Next Step to Delivering a Better Employee Experience Through AI with Vidatec
Learn More About our AI Consulting Services
We cut through the AI hype to help you understand what actually works in your specific situation. Drawing from 300+ real-world projects, we help you implement AI in simple, practical steps that actually stick and deliver results.
Watch our 30-Minute Expert-Led AI Webinar
Hear directly from our CEO, Ross Wilson, and CTO, Nick Welch, as they provide a framework to assess your organisation’s AI readiness and outline practical tools and strategies to implement a true human-first AI implementation.
Meet the author

Matt Graham
UI/UX Lead








